Tuesday, December 11, 2007

"Awareness" does not equal INFORMATION

At this point, anyone who reads here who doesn't know about the NYU Ransom Notes campaign hasn't been to a computer in the past few weeks. Therefore, I am not going to further their traffic by linking back to them. They're just counting hits, not reading what the referrers say. Y'all also already know that ASAN is organizing all sorts of stuff against this horrid campaign.

You ALSO probably know that the people defending it-namely those in charge of the shock ya for ya dollah ads-are saying it is OK that it pisses off most of the people who both see it AND are acquainted with a clue because "it raises awareness".

Ah, awareness. Kind of like those Middle Ages indulgences, you can do whatever you want and get out of the consequences, so long as you invoke "awareness". A whole lot cheaper than building a cathedral, too.

Newsflash: "Awareness" isn't the same thing as "information". Every Condition Du Jour has had the "OMGZ IT EATS PEEPLEZ!" days. I remember that they were going on with autism WHEN I WAS IN *HIGH SCHOOL*. I graduated in 2001. That was a long time ago, yes?

To contrast with 2 other hysteria campaigns (only these turned into information, which appears to be anathema when related to autism)...please note that the only thing most of these conditions have in common with autism is that they had a hysteria campaign that I am old enough to remember:

-HIV/AIDS: I remember this campaign starting when I was about 7. People being afraid to catch AIDS from toilet seats/kisses/hugs/paper towels/the air. Seriously. Thus, it became impossible to blow one's nose in any public restroom. Several years later, I was in MAYBE 4th or 5th grade, there is a feature in American Girl Magazine about a little girl who is HIV+ and takes an antiretroviral cocktail and goes to school and you can't get AIDS from casual contact or the bathroom or anything but needles and certain body fluids. Yeah. Three year turnaround on a disease that is serious shit.

-Cancer: They're bound and determined to say autism is like cancer, here's yet another reason that it ISN'T. I knew that you needed a pap smear and a mammogram or you die when I was in 3rd grade. I knew what they were while still in grade school. The whole public knows signs and has pink ribbons, and has since I was in junior high. There are prostate exam commercials all over the airwaves, including signs that you need one, and in my lifetime they've come up with real facts beyond get a mammogram and a pap smear or you die. Like that viruses cause HPV which causes cervical cancer, and that mammogramming a 32A is a waste of everyone's time and you need an ultrasound instead. And there was that whole Live Strong thing too...

Do they need autism to be more hysterical because it DOESN'T kill people? Is that it? Do they not know how to present anything but negatives? I seriously do not know. Because these were both in the span of grade school (I am so too fried to even be writing this but it needs said now not later) and the autism hysteria has lasted LONGER than I've been in the autism game, which is about 8 years.

Between the "all autistics are children" rhetoric (where's my plane home?) and the "autistics are empty shells of nothing but devestating deficits" I am so disgusted with so called awareness.

I want to see information already.

Labels: , , , , ,

9 Comments:

Blogger abfh said...

Medieval indulgences -- yes, that's exactly what it seems like. I guess that would make us Martin Luther, nailing our blogs to the church door?

I've tagged you for a blogging award.

December 12, 2007 11:28 AM  
Blogger Marla said...

Well said. It is easy in life to just be "aware" of things and not work to understand them. Awareness seems to be a cop out, especially how it is being talked about in these ads.

December 12, 2007 9:53 PM  
Blogger Tera said...


Newsflash: "Awareness" isn't the same thing as "information".


Exactly.

I'm not sure who these ads are supposed to make "aware." If it's parents in denial that their kid has a disability (as has been argued), how will these ads convince them otherwise, unless (maybe) the kid is already diagnosed with one of these conditions?

These ads don't list diagnostic signs at all. And the stuff they do list is alarmist, stereotyped, and incorrect. (What autistic person is completely unable to interact socially? And nobody with ADHD--or any other disabled person--has ever been a detriment to me, ever).

So, basically, all they are is a bunch of really scary imagery attached to psychiatric labels, which is incredibly vague. (Ooh! Disabilities are scary! How novel and destigmatizing, NYU Child Study Center!).

Speaking of which, the whole "psychiatric label=kidnapping/ torture/killing" thing has already been done in, like, every slasher movie ever made. Shifting the stereotype slightly still taps into that.

December 12, 2007 10:12 PM  
Blogger daedalus2u said...

What is so sad, and actually quite pathetic is that it takes people with autism to understand how hurtful this stuff is.

We are the ones who are supposed to be "empty shells".

I do appreciate that some NTs appreciate it is hurtful too, but it seems like they are a tiny minority (but a much loved and appreciated minority).

December 13, 2007 4:25 PM  
Blogger Ed said...

Kassianne,
I'm really glad whenever you post something.These comparisons are very good. You make alot of sense. Thanks

December 15, 2007 8:50 PM  
Blogger mumkeepingsane said...

Everything you wrote is exactly spot on! I've been so afraid that my 5 yr old son will read these ads. I'm pretty sure I don't want him to see that some people think he's an empty shell.

Terrible, awful, dangerous campaign. grrrrrrrr.

December 18, 2007 7:58 AM  
Blogger Casdok said...

Great post.

December 22, 2007 2:49 AM  
Blogger Marla said...

Hope you are doing well. Enjoy the holidays!

December 24, 2007 9:24 AM  
Blogger Ettina said...

http://demonized.autistics.org/ has a lot about the 'empty shell' idea.

January 29, 2008 4:15 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home